Close Menu
Pop Icon Magazine
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Pop Icon Magazine
    • Home
    • Celebrity News
    • Movies
    • Television
    • Music
    • Books
    • Fashion & Style
    • Horror
    • Cover Story
    • Contact us
      • About us
      • Amazon Disclaimer
      • DMCA / Copyrights Disclaimer
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
    Pop Icon Magazine
    Home»Television»Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5 Review: Cathy Is Doing Too Much, But the Boys Will Be Alright
    Television

    Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5 Review: Cathy Is Doing Too Much, But the Boys Will Be Alright

    AdminBy AdminSeptember 9, 2026
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp
    Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5 Review: Cathy Is Doing Too Much, But the Boys Will Be Alright

    This trip, fraught with danger, death, and mayhem, is bringing out the worst in some people.

    And by some people, I mean Kathy.

    Honestly, what is her deal?

    (Paramount+)

    After Imani was taken at the tail end of Average Joe Season 2 Episode 4, I assumed the next hour would open with her in Sipho’s home, likely in the worst possible situation since Sipho is unwell.

    But instead, Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5 picked up right where the last hour left off, and Joe wasn’t about to let Imani go.

    • Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5 Review: Cathy Is Doing Too Much, But the Boys Will Be Alright
      by Whitney Evans
    • The Paper Season 2 Review: Keep Your Friends Close and Your Co-Workers Closer
      by Sam Huang
    • Reacher Season 4 Episode 7’s Explosive Hour Did In Fact “Snap That Shit” — And It Was Glorious
      by Jasmine Blu

    At its core, Average Joe is a story about family, but it’s also a small-time action flick come to life, and some hours, that’s the best part.

    It’s bloody, brutal, and comical all at once, with action that feels anything but run-of-the-mill. And while this hour started action-packed, with Joe racing down the streets of Africa and Imani fighting off her captors, that was essentially all the action we got.

    And it was a little disappointing, if only because they’re so damn good at it, so when it’s missing, it’s noticeable.

    (Paramount+)

    Instead of gunfights and explosions, this hour stepped back from the chaos and offered a more introspective look at various characters.

    And it’s nice to get more backstory for the newer characters, but it also felt like all the forward momentum of the season, regarding Teddy’s clues and all the forward momentum surrounding Teddy’s clues and the reason they’re in Africa to begin with, took a backseat.

    One character we got to explore more was Sipho, and it’s never a bad thing to give the big bad villain some shading so they’re more than just the evil thing trying to bring down the good guys.

    The flashbacks, which Average Joe employs to dazzling effect every time, showed us the moment Sipho became the crime lord we see today. Or at least we saw what pushed him in that direction.

    A young Sipho, whose real name was not Sipho, watched his mother get murdered, along with countless other people, while he was at church, which should be the safest place in the world.

    (Paramount+)

    Instead, to him, it’s tainted and something else entirely.

    When the man responsible for the slaughter tried to basically imprint upon him while he was still wearing his mother’s blood on him, he did what anyone in that situation would do: he played along.

    @media (max-width: 768px) {
    .tvf-google-cta {
    padding: 22px 14px !important;
    }

    .tvf-google-cta p {
    font-size: 22px !important;
    line-height: 1.25 !important;
    margin-bottom: 16px !important;
    }

    .tvf-google-cta a {
    font-size: 14px !important;
    padding: 10px 18px !important;
    border-radius: 34px !important;
    line-height: 1.3 !important;
    }
    }

    Add TV Fanatic as a Trusted Source on Google!


    Get More of Our Coverage!

    But when given the chance to strike, he took it. And though he looked terrified—a young boy growing up in the blink of an eye—he killed the soldier, took his name, and eventually became someone cruel, belligerently drunk with power, and utterly consumed by the violence that had made him.

    Average Joe takes great pains to explore both relationships and who these people are, even while giving us the big action sequences and the off-color humor.

    Seeing Sipho’s origins helped his later outburst make a lot more sense.

    (Paramount+)

    He’s a mean-spirited person at his core, but his outburst was the only way he knew how to deal with even the slightest discomfort, stress, or fear.

    When he awakens from his slumber, I’m fully expecting him to be on the warpath.

    While Sipho’s backstory was explored subtly, we also learned a lot more about Phyllis and, in turn, Touch.

    The connection between Touch and Phyllis has been evident since Average Joe Season 2 Episode 2, but learning about her sister makes it much more apparent why she felt so strongly for Touch immediately, and why she refused to give up on him.

    As a healer, Phyllis had to have felt a tremendous sense of loss and anger when her sister passed, even if it was ultimately not her fault. You take on a lot as a sangoma, and that responsibility must have made the loss even harder to bear.

    (Paramount+)

    With Touch, she saw him for who he was: a drug addict carrying a tremendous amount of pain inside, and waltzing around with a death wish and a need to put his life on the line every chance he got.

    She was never scared of that; instead, she basically doubled down on helping him until he finally pushed her away one too many times.

    Opinion Piece

    Dear Medical Dramas, Please Abandon This Tired Trope

    Jack Ori – September 8, 2026 – 1 Reply

    News Opinion Piece

    Dutton Ranch Season 2: The Biggest Changes You Need to Know

    Siddhika Prajapati – September 7, 2026

    Classic TV Opinion Piece

    I Finally Watched One of Buffy’s Most Controversial Episodes — And I Almost Quit the Show

    Sam Huang – September 4, 2026 – 2 Replies

    Opinion Piece Reality TV

    Big Brother 28: Who Has the Best Odds of Winning the Jury Vote?

    Justin Carreiro – September 4, 2026

    Opinion Piece Trailers

    New Era, New Tony, Same Epic Bromance: NCIS Season 24’s Trailer Knows How to Tease & Please

    Jasmine Blu – September 2, 2026 – 6 Replies

    The only thing that got them to true honesty was the fear Imani’s rogue mission instilled in her. And the vulnerability they shared was honestly beautiful, as was her journey into the spiritual realm, where she saw Donna.

    Aside from one character we’ll get to later, I believe that underneath a lot of bravado, all of these people are good. They make mistakes, loads of them, and they have their moments, but they have good hearts, even if it takes a while to see them.

    Touch isn’t a perfect person, and he’s got a lot of work to do on himself, but he does have love within him. And you see that love in his friendship with Joe and Leon, two people he’d go to the ends of the earth for.

    (Paramount+)

    But he lives in a perpetual state of agony, never really allowing himself to either live or love fully.

    Donna telling Phyllis that the truth will set Touch free was a little cliché, but it was also exactly what Touch needed to hear, because he keeps everything inside and never lets himself be vulnerable or lean on the people who love him.

    So many people bottle things up out of fear, embarrassment, or simply because they don’t want to burden others, never recognizing how detrimental that can be.

    “The truth will set you free” is a cliché, but it’s rooted in truth.

    Perhaps the most beautiful moment of the whole series was seeing Touch finally confide in his brothers, all the ugly, hard truths. And they didn’t run from him; instead, they embraced him, and in that moment, you could see how much freer Touch felt.

    (Paramount+)

    It was honestly a moment that made me a little misty-eyed because that’s what family is really about.

    It’s a shame Cathy’s farce of an apology preceded it.

    I’ve watched enough television to know that I probably shouldn’t jump to conclusions, especially when a show like Average Joe can pull a bait-and-switch on the audience in a heartbeat.

    • The Paper Co-Creators Greg Daniels and Michael Koman Talk Finding Humor in Humanity in Season 2
      by Sam Huang
    • Last Seen Stars Reveal the Unexpected Hope at the Heart of Apple TV’s Devastating New Thriller
      by Carissa Pavlica
    • Haunted Harmony Mysteries: Tamera Mowry-Housley on Gethsemane’s Evolution, the Growing Love Triangle & More
      by Laura Nowak

    But we’ve seen Cathy be selfish enough to think the worst first and then beg for forgiveness later.

    I’ll always maintain that Cathy loves Leon, but does Cathy love Leon more than she loves herself? Should she?

    (Paramount+)

    I think there’s a real conversation to be had about Cathy being her own person and not being content just to be someone’s wife, but the argument for Cathy loses its luster when Cathy goes out of her way to sabotage her husband and the people he loves.

    Teddy’s clues leading them to some dangerous bar where they stuck out like a sore thumb, only for them to make some inroads, and then Cathy call the cops and put them in greater danger?

    Is she okay?

    Cathy may have a bigger plan that we can’t see yet, and the guys will end up thanking her for her forward, progressive, intuitive thinking. But right now it feels like Cathy being Cathy, meaning she’s being petty for the hell of it.

    Even if it all works out, it’s her going behind their backs AGAIN that’s disheartening, tiring, and worthy of those men truly never believing a thing she says.

    (Paramount+)

    Extra, Average Notes

    • The guys’ spirited debate about R&B singers and bands, while singing September, is the kind of scene that makes this show so unique and fun. They’ve almost been killed a million times, but they can still have a little fun.
    • Big Brother Spoilers: Veto Meeting Results Set Up a Fascinating Week 9 Eviction
      by Paul Dailly
    • Big Brother Spoilers: Veto Winner Revealed, and It’s Bad News for the Icons
      by Paul Dailly
    • Big Brother Spoilers: The Power Structure Has Finally Cracked
      by Whitney Evans
    • Phyllis getting to see Jamila and her sister was so sweet. And getting a message back to Imani? Priceless.
    • I keep waiting for Sipho to connect Imani and Phyllis and show up at her store.
    • We still need more context on Akinyemi’s tragedy, but how can you not feel absolutely gutted for him? He’s throwing himself into his work, which he’s good at, but he’s not handling his grief.
    (Paramount+)

    It was a slower hour in a season that is moving at breakneck speed.

    If you’re watching, please drop a comment below and let me know how you’re enjoying this season so far.

    I’d love to chat with you!

    New episodes of Average Joe air every Wednesday through September 30, only on Paramount+.

    {“poll”:{“id”:”2053″,”name”:”Grade Rate Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5!”,”template”:”3″,”template_base”:”classic”,”skin_base”:”green-v3″,”status”:”published”,”meta_data”:{“style”:{“poll”:{“backgroundColor”:”#f7feff”,”borderSize”:10,”borderStyle”:”solid”,”borderColor”:”#00a2c7″,”borderRadius”:5,”paddingLeftRight”:10,”paddingTopBottom”:10},”questions”:{“paddingLeftRight”:0,”paddingTopBottom”:10,”textColor”:”#000000″,”textSize”:22,”textWeight”:”bold”,”textAlign”:”center”},”answers”:{“paddingLeftRight”:0,”paddingTopBottom”:0,”textColor”:”#000000″,”textSize”:18,”textWeight”:”normal”,”skin”:”minimal”,”colorScheme”:”black”},”buttons”:{“backgroundColor”:”#000000″,”borderSize”:1,”borderStyle”:”solid”,”borderColor”:”#000000″,”borderRadius”:5,”paddingLeftRight”:10,”paddingTopBottom”:10,”textColor”:”#ffffff”,”textSize”:20,”textWeight”:”bold”,”align”:”center”},”errors”:{“borderLeftColorForSuccess”:”#000000″,”borderLeftColorForError”:”#ff0000″,”borderLeftSize”:10,”paddingTopBottom”:0,”textColor”:”#000000″,”textSize”:18,”textWeight”:”normal”},”custom”:{“css”:””}},”options”:{“poll”:{“voteButtonLabel”:”Vote”,”showResultsLink”:”no”,”resultsLabelText”:”Results”,”showTotalVotes”:”no”,”showTotalAnswers”:”no”,”startDateOption”:”now”,”startDateCustom”:””,”endDateOption”:”never”,”endDateCustom”:””,”redirectAfterVote”:”no”,”redirectUrl”:””,”redirectAfter”:””,”pageId”:””,”pageLink”:””,”useCaptcha”:”no”,”enableGdpr”:”no”,”gdprSolution”:”ask_consent”,”gdprConsentText”:””,”loadWithAjax”:”no”,”notificationMessageLocation”:”top”,”status”:”published”},”results”:{“showResultsMoment”:[“after-vote”],”customDateResults”:””,”showResultsTo”:[“guest”,”registered”],”resultsDetails”:[“percentages”],”backToVoteOption”:”no”,”backToVoteCaption”:”Back to vote”,”sortResults”:”as-defined”,”sortResultsRule”:”asc”,”displayResultsAs”:”bar”},”access”:{“votePermissions”:[“guest”,”wordpress”]}}}},”elements”:[{“id”:”2088″,”poll_id”:”2053″,”etext”:”Rate Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5!”,”etype”:”question-text”,”status”:”active”,”sorder”:”0″,”meta_data”:{“isRequired”:”yes”,”allowMultipleAnswers”:”no”,”allowOtherAnswers”:”no”,”answersDisplay”:”vertical”,”answersColumns”:””,”answersAlign”:”left”,”answersSort”:”as-defined”,”multipleAnswersMinim”:”1″,”multipleAnswersMaxim”:”1″,”otherAnswersLabel”:”Other”,”otherAnswersCount”:1,”otherAnswersType”:”single-line”,”otherFieldSize”:”small”,”otherMaxChars”:”0″,”addOtherAnswers”:”no”,”displayOtherAnswersInResults”:”no”,”resultsColorForOtherAnswers”:”#000000″},”subelements”:[{“id”:”17152″,”poll_id”:”2053″,”element_id”:”2088″,”stext”:”5 Stars”,”stype”:”text”,”status”:”active”,”sorder”:”0″,”meta_data”:{“makeDefault”:”0″,”makeLink”:”0″,”link”:””,”resultsColor”:”#000000″}},{“id”:”17153″,”poll_id”:”2053″,”element_id”:”2088″,”stext”:”4 Stars”,”stype”:”text”,”status”:”active”,”sorder”:”1″,”meta_data”:{“makeDefault”:”0″,”makeLink”:”0″,”link”:””,”resultsColor”:”#000000″}},{“id”:”17154″,”poll_id”:”2053″,”element_id”:”2088″,”stext”:”3 Stars”,”stype”:”text”,”status”:”active”,”sorder”:”2″,”meta_data”:{“makeDefault”:”0″,”makeLink”:”0″,”link”:””,”resultsColor”:”#000000″}},{“id”:”17155″,”poll_id”:”2053″,”element_id”:”2088″,”stext”:”2 Stars”,”stype”:”text”,”status”:”active”,”sorder”:”3″,”meta_data”:{“makeDefault”:”0″,”makeLink”:”0″,”link”:””,”resultsColor”:”#000000″}},{“id”:”17156″,”poll_id”:”2053″,”element_id”:”2088″,”stext”:”1 Star”,”stype”:”text”,”status”:”active”,”sorder”:”4″,”meta_data”:{“makeDefault”:”0″,”makeLink”:”0″,”link”:””,”resultsColor”:”#000000″}}]}],”messages”:{“buttons”:{“anonymous”:”Anonymous Vote”,”wordpress”:”Sign in with WordPress”,”facebook”:”Sign in with Facebook”,”google”:”Sign in with Google”},”voting”:{“poll-ended”:”This poll is no longer accepting votes”,”poll-not-started”:”This poll is not accepting votes yet”,”already-voted-on-poll”:”Thank you for your vote”,”invalid-poll”:”Invalid Poll”,”no-answers-selected”:”No answer selected”,”min-answers-required”:”At least {min_answers_allowed} answer(s) required”,”max-answers-required”:”A max of {max_answers_allowed} answer(s) accepted”,”no-answer-for-other”:”No other answer entered”,”answer-for-other-too-long”:”Answer for other is too long”,”no-value-for-custom-field”:”{custom_field_name} is required”,”too-many-chars-for-custom-field”:”Text for {custom_field_name} is too long”,”invalid-value-for-email”:”Invalid Email”,”consent-not-checked”:”You must agree to our terms and conditions”,”no-captcha-selected”:”Captcha is required”,”not-allowed-by-ban”:”Vote not allowed”,”not-allowed-by-block”:”Vote not allowed”,”not-allowed-by-limit”:”Vote not allowed”,”thank-you”:”Thank you for your vote”},”results”:{“single-vote”:”vote”,”multiple-votes”:”votes”,”single-answer”:”answer”,”multiple-answers”:”answers”},”captcha”:{“accessibility-alt”:”Sound icon”,”accessibility-title”:”Accessibility option: listen to a question and answer it!”,”accessibility-description”:”Type below the [STRONG]answer[\/STRONG] to what you hear. Numbers or words:”,”explanation”:”Click or touch the [STRONG]ANSWER[\/STRONG]”,”refresh-alt”:”Refresh\/reload icon”,”refresh-title”:”Refresh\/reload: get new images and accessibility option!”}},”date_format”:”F j, Y”,”nonce”:”8539759d38″,”page_id”:898275,”tracking_id”:”https:\/\/www.tvfanatic.com\/feed”}
    • Best Lines from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Season 4 Episode 7, “Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass”

      Best Lines from Star Trek: Strange New Worlds Season 4 Episode 7, “Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass”

      Trelane hit Star Trek: Strange New Worlds “Like Chronitons Through the Hourglass” with soapy melodrama. Did you cringe or LOL at these lines?

    • Outer Banks Season 5 Character Rankings No One Asked For (But Everyone Needs)

      Outer Banks Season 5 Character Rankings No One Asked For (But Everyone Needs)

      Who really won Outer Banks Season 5? We ranked all nine main characters by their choices, chaos, and comedic value. Spoiler: it’s not John B.

    • Fury, Fight, Feels: Furious, Anna Pigeon & More Put Their Characters Through Hell — And We Couldn’t Look Away

      Fury, Fight, Feels: Furious, Anna Pigeon & More Put Their Characters Through Hell — And We Couldn’t Look Away

      Anna Pigeon, Furious, Ted Lasso, and All American all know there’s brilliance behind putting characters through hell. Our Characters of the Week.

    The post Average Joe Season 2 Episode 5 Review: Cathy Is Doing Too Much, But the Boys Will Be Alright appeared first on TV Fanatic.

    Originally Published Here.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp
    Previous Article‘Who’s’ Next? It’s A New War On Drugs Song
    Next Article Chris Hansen Slams Robert Pattinson’s Primetime for Turning Predator Sting Into a Horror Movie

    Related Posts

    Savannah Chrisley Reveals Big Wedding Plans As Nanny Faye Disagrees

    November 12, 2026

    Stassi Schroeder Reveals Comments That Sent Her Into A Mini Depression

    November 12, 2026

    Todd Chrisley Goes Off On Haters Fat-Shaming Pregnant Savannah

    November 12, 2026

    Gwen Stefani Reunites With Ex In Rare Outing For Emotional Occasion

    November 12, 2026

    90 Day: The Last Resort Season 4 Alleged Cast & Location Revealed

    November 12, 2026

    Bachelor Peter Weber Reveals Surprise Engagement Amid Twin Pregnancy

    November 12, 2026
    Popular Posts

    Coachella 2027 Passes Are Sold Out

    Music

    Deep Cut Friday: Lost in the Supermarket by the Clash – SPIN

    Music

    Interview with Christy Scott Cashman, Author of What Happened in Beulah

    Books

    Travis Barker Says He Stopped Smoking Weed After Being Diagnosed With Precancer of the Esophagus

    Celebrity News

    Why Hasnt Joran van der Sloot Been Charged in Natalee Holloways Murder? Legal Hurdles Explained

    Celebrity News

    2027 Download Fest Features blink-182, BMTH, Evanescence, Turnstile, Faith No More

    Music

    Savannah Chrisley Reveals Big Wedding Plans As Nanny Faye Disagrees

    Television
    Music

    In Photos: The Art of Metallica Exhibit Opens in San Francisco

    Music

    Alan Pierson Takes Steve Reichs 18 Musicians On A Journey Through Time – SPIN

    Music

    Following the Family Ties – SPIN

    Music

    Nile Rodgers Defends His Use of AI in New Music Video: Youre Being Hypocritical

    Music

    Ozzfest Rising Again For Three 2027 Dates – SPIN

    Music
    Categories
    • Books (3,170)
    • Celebrity News (2,980)
    • Cover Story (63)
    • Fashion & Style (2,308)
    • Horror (2,929)
    • Movies (3,617)
    • Music (4,080)
    • Politics (8)
    • Television (3,327)
    Movies

    The Pitt Season 3: Fan-Favorite Actor Confirms Return Despite Reduced Season 2 Role

    Movies

    Paul Bettany Reveals Bloody VisionQuest Set Injury Caused By Wildly Overacting

    Movies

    The Mandalorians Ming-Na Wen Poses a Question to Star Wars Fans in New Video

    Movies

    Popular Paramount+ Show Is Finally Coming to Its End After 20 Seasons

    Movies

    Reese Witherspoon Makes Surprising Career Pivot Weeks After Major Business Deal

    Movies
    Horror

    An Eloping Couple Faces a Death Cult in Horror Pic Father Figure

    Horror

    Richard Armitage to Play a Terrifying Hunter in Horror Pic Chinghiale

    Horror

    Jessica Rothe, Cooper Tomlinson and Mika Abdalla to Star in Ride-Share Horror Film Seeker

    Horror

    The Devils Is an NC-17 Box Office Hit as Warner Bros. Teases November 10

    Horror

    Hellraiser: Revival: Team Unofficially Wanted to be Banned

    Horror
    Archives
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit TikTok
    © 2026 Pop Icon Magazine. All rights reserved. All articles, images, product names, logos, and brands are property of their respective owners. All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes only. Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement unless specified. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.