Close Menu
Pop Icon Magazine
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Pop Icon Magazine
    • Home
    • Celebrity News
    • Movies
    • Television
    • Music
    • Books
    • Fashion & Style
    • Horror
    • Cover Story
    • Contact us
      • About us
      • Amazon Disclaimer
      • DMCA / Copyrights Disclaimer
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms and Conditions
    Pop Icon Magazine
    Home»Television»Oscars 2024: As Critics Blast ‘Boring’ Ceremony, Is It Time to Move on From the Traditional Award Show Format?
    Television

    Oscars 2024: As Critics Blast ‘Boring’ Ceremony, Is It Time to Move on From the Traditional Award Show Format?

    AdminBy AdminMarch 11, 2024
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp
    Oscars 2024: As Critics Blast ‘Boring’ Ceremony, Is It Time to Move on From the Traditional Award Show Format?


    This was supposed to be a big year for the Academy Awards.


    The battle between Barbie and Oppenheimer that had been raging all award season (and that began when both films hit theaters on the same day back in July) promised a level of enthusiasm for Hollywood’s biggest night that would hearken back to the Oscars’ most recent heyday in the ’90s.


    That was an era in which the tastes of Hollywood bigwigs and average moviegoers widely overlapped, resulting in Best Picture wins for popular favorites like The Silence of the Lambs, Unforgiven, Forrest Gump, and Titanic.

    Jimmy Kimmel Hosts the Oscars


    Needless to say, the first movies of the 2020s to take home the industry’s biggest prize — Nomadland, CODA, and Everything Everywhere All at Once —  haven’t achieved quite the same level of populist appeal.


    Which is one reason why Academy Award ratings these days look so shockingly paltry when compared to the 58 million who tuned in for James Cameron’s “king of the world” moment in 1998.

    James Cameron Pic


    The first three Oscars broadcasts of the decade failed to crack the 20 million-viewer mark, and in recent years, the “Hollywood’s biggest night” label has felt less like an accurate description and more like a sadly ironic callback to the days when middle America genuinely cared about the show.


    But this was the year that promised to turn the trend around, not only in terms of viewership but with regard to the cultural discourse.


    The year of Barbenheimer promised to be the year that the Oscars recaptured Peoria.


    Why, then, did the ceremony fail to generate the sort of buzz commensurate with the billion-dollar flicks that dominated the year’s trade headlines?


    Ratings aren’t out yet, but social media engagement indicates that interest in the show was no higher than it was at any other point this decade.

    Oppenheimer Image


    (Obviously, the moment in 2022 when Will Smith slapped Chris Rock is an outlier. That was one of the most widely discussed celebrity news items of the 21st century, but it’s not the sort of scene that the Academy can take pride in.


    Host Jimmy Kimmel received mixed reviews, with some outlets blasting the ceremony as “boring” and uninspired.


    “The Oscar broadcast didn’t feel like anybody’s biggest night,” wrote Kelly Lawler of USA Today.


    “It felt small, unimportant, skippable. It didn’t get anywhere close to the urgency or relevancy of the nominated films. Ken might be enough, but Oscar certainly isn’t.”


    Part of the problem is that now more than ever, Americans are simply not on the same page. About anything.

    Emma Stone in Poor Things


    Our sensibilities are all over the map, which is how we end up with a situation in which some viewers decry Kimmel’s opening monologue as needlessly coarse, while others gripe that the show lacked an edge.


    So the days of a consensus reaction to any given year’s Academy Awards broadcast might be well behind us.


    (For that matter, the days of Americans seeing eye-to-eye on any matter at all might be behind us, but we don’t want to get too bleak on a Monday.)


    But from the Academy’s standpoint, it’s okay if the country disagrees on the quality of the show, just so long as they’re talking about it.


    And that should’ve been a low hurdle to clear, as this was the first time in years that the Best Picture front-runners were bonafide blockbusters that raked in record box office.

    Gloria - Barbie (2023)


    But the Oscars have the same problem as every other entertainment industry award show in that they’re asking regular folk to take an interest in a ceremony that mostly consists of millionaires congratulating each other.


    For every populous moment like Ryan Gosling assuming the role of a Ken doll for an old-school musical number, there were several self-congratulatory ones.


    The decision, for example, to relive the glory of Oscars past (and extend the show’s runtime on a school night) by trotting out five presenters for every acting category demonstrated a lack of understanding of why the average viewer tunes in.


    As usual, there were political moments, and as usual, they had a divisive effect on social media users.


    Amateur pundits were mostly on board with 20 Days In Mariupol director Mstyslav Chernov decrying Russia’s invasion of Ukraine during his Best Documentary acceptance speech.

    Ryan Gosling at the Oscars


    Public opinion was much more split with regard to Kimmel’s decision to read Donald Trump‘s Truth Social posts about the Oscars.


    Even Twitter/X users who are critical of Trump felt that Kimmel was guilty of taking the bait and “feeding the troll” and would have been much better off denying 45 a platform.


    Maybe that moment and the reaction to it highlighted exactly why the Oscars will never be able to regain their former prominence.


    We may have reached the point where we’re no longer capable of temporarily shutting off the parts of our brain most prone to criticism so that we might simply enjoy three hours of beautiful people patting each other on the back.

    The Holdovers


    And that might be a good thing for society as a whole!


    But it’s a bad thing for award shows, and as the granddaddy of them all, the Oscars have the most to lose.


    We recommend handing next year’s hosting duties to the night’s best presenter, John Mulaney, in a last-ditch effort to switch things up!


    What did you think, TV fans? Are the Oscars toast? Hit the comments section below to share your thoughts.

    Tyler Johnson is an Associate Editor for TV Fanatic and the other Mediavine O&O sites. In his spare time, he enjoys reading, cooking, and, of course, watching TV. You can Follow him on X and email him here at TV Fanatic.

    Originally Published Here.

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Reddit WhatsApp
    Previous Article‘HappyLand’: Alamo Drafthouse Naples Announces Mini Golf Course Featuring Iconic Hollywood Creatures
    Next Article Ozark Season 4 Teaser Trailer and First Look Photos Reveal New Faces in the Final Season

    Related Posts

    Kris Jenner Shares Shocking Confession About Rob Kardashian Sr. Relationship

    November 20, 2026

    Boston Blue Donnie Wahlberg Mourns Heartbreaking Loss

    November 20, 2026

    DWTS Pro Called Out By Fans For Recycling Old Routines

    November 20, 2026

    Savannah Chrisley Reveals Big Wedding Plans As Nanny Faye Disagrees

    November 12, 2026

    Stassi Schroeder Reveals Comments That Sent Her Into A Mini Depression

    November 12, 2026

    Todd Chrisley Goes Off On Haters Fat-Shaming Pregnant Savannah

    November 12, 2026
    Popular Posts

    Rockstar Leaves Sex Workers Out of Grand Theft Auto for First Time in 25 Years

    Music

    Interview with Aletheia von Gottlieb, Author of Love Off the Ice (Sweet Snowfall Kisses Book 1)

    Books

    Glastonbury Glows With Styles, Eilish, Fender, Cher – SPIN

    Music

    RHOBHs Dorit Kemsley Teases Fresh Start in New Home With Kids After Eviction Amid PK Divorce

    Celebrity News

    Who Is Anne Hathaways Husband? Meet Adam Shulman Amid Baby No. 3s Arrival

    Celebrity News

    Pearl Jam Hoping To Play Shows In 2027 – SPIN

    Music

    Sweet Relief 2027 Benefit Will Honor Elvis Costello With Ben Gibbard, Rufus Wainwright, Fred Armisen, More

    Music
    Music

    King Gizzard Crafts Its Second Techno Album Of 2026 – SPIN

    Music

    Faith No More Welcome Back Guitarist Trey Spruance for 2027 Reunion Tour

    Music

    Rocky Kramer’s Rock & Roll Tuesdays Presents “Con Man” On Tuesday, November 10th, 2026 7 PM PT on Twitch

    Celebrity News

    Why Jack Kays Came Back to 38 North Studio – SPIN

    Music

    Paul McCartney and Ringo Starr Set for Rare Reunion in January

    Music
    Categories
    • Books (3,176)
    • Celebrity News (2,988)
    • Cover Story (63)
    • Fashion & Style (2,308)
    • Horror (2,938)
    • Movies (3,626)
    • Music (4,088)
    • Politics (8)
    • Television (3,336)
    Movies

    Superman & Peacemaker Stars Break Silence on James Gunns DCU Exit

    Movies

    New DC Boss Viral Video Has Fans Thinking the Same Thing About Movies Like Clayface

    Movies

    General Hospital Officially Recasts a Key Character, New Actor Makes Debut

    Movies

    Liam Neesons New, Ultra-Dark Action Flick Is Being Compared to One of the1970s Silliest Movies

    Movies

    Nicole Kidmans Big Little Lies Season 3 Gets Great Filming Update, But Theres a Catch

    Movies
    Horror

    Tragedy Man: Nicholas Denton and Tim Downie to Star as Horror Legends Michael Reeves and Vincent Price

    Horror

    Return of the Living Dead Stars Speak Out About AI in Aftermath: This Is Not What We Signed Up For

    Horror

    Longlegs Star Alicia Witt to Lead Surrogacy Horror Thriller Incuba Project

    Horror

    Lili Reinhart, Mark Duplass and Others Join Psychosexual Horror Film Violet from Creep Director!

    Horror

    Maya Hawke to Star in Magic: The Gathering Live-Action Pic from Legendary and Hasbro!

    Horror
    Archives
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest YouTube LinkedIn WhatsApp Reddit TikTok
    © 2026 Pop Icon Magazine. All rights reserved. All articles, images, product names, logos, and brands are property of their respective owners. All company, product and service names used in this website are for identification purposes only. Use of these names, logos, and brands does not imply endorsement unless specified. By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.