Grey’s Anatomy Is at an Impasse – Did It Fumble the Perfect Reset?

Sometimes, it’s difficult to even process that Grey’s Anatomy has been on the air for over 20 years, which is how long we’ve been bringing you Grey’s content here at TV Fanatic.

It’s no small feat for us or Grey’s, especially in this television landscape where if a series doesn’t immediately grab an audience’s attention, it can get shuffled off the air mere moments later.

What’s crucial to a series like Grey’s Anatomy’s longevity lies in its ability to reinvent itself and stay relevant. But there’s one issue these days: it’s struggling to do that at all.

And when it comes to pinpointing just why the series is floundering and boring more often than not, the answer is quite simple: it completely fumbled the perfect reset.

A significant part of the appeal when Grey’s Anatomy premiered in 2005 was its core group of characters, who viewers instantly gravitated to, and the type of bonds they forged as the chaos and messiness, professional and otherwise, at Seattle Grace consumed them.

Many characters have come and gone over the years, but it’s M.A.G.I.C. (Meredith Grey, Alex Karev, George O’Malley, Izzie Stevens, and Cristina Yang) who viewers still hold onto.

Grey’s Anatomy marked a resurgence of a strong ensemble cast, at the time, composed of fresh faces and mostly unknown or lesser-known talents. And it paid off.

It was also refreshingly diverse, not just in regards to race and gender, but lifestyles and backgrounds, which was reflected well throughout the storylines.

The original group of baby-faced, competitive, and at times arrogant interns, along with the attendings and mentors around them, had us glued to the screens through LVAD wire cuttings, a ridiculous number of tragedies, and steamy on-call room hookups.

They didn’t feel like just characters we were watching onscreen, but friends, messy, flawed, just as confused when it came to navigating life as the rest of us.

At its core, Grey’s Anatomy understood that, and we got many glorious years of that quality, even as the core group shifted and shrank as more people departed the series.

Meredith’s evolution — going from a jaded, naive intern to one of the most esteemed, award-winning doctors in her field and a mother — is a satisfying arc and a great payoff for people who have followed the series through its entire run.

But the key to Grey’s Anatomy’s spark has always lain in a core group of individuals with wonder in their eyes as they come into their own as friends, foes, lovers, but most importantly, doctors.

Over the years, Grey’s Anatomy tried to recapture the magic of M.A.G.I.C., but often felt like it didn’t fully commit to it.

We had some standouts over the years. Most people can recall Stephanie, Jo, and Shane as the most memorable from the class, but things didn’t exactly pan out for everyone but Jo in the end.

No one really remembers anyone outside of Lexie in her class.

DeLuca was the only real standout in his class simply because he got the most screen time. At the same time, colleagues like Sam Bello were shuffled out via Grey’s hollow, contrived storylines posing as social commentary.

At one point, we had Helm, Levi, Casey Parker, Vikram, and Dahlia, poised to recapture the iconic intern energy, but then their class quietly fell apart.

Part of the issue was a sense of box-checking: trans character, hijabi Muslim character, gay nerd, snarky lesbian, one of the shockingly few Southeast Asian characters on a medical drama.

Representation matters deeply, but representation without follow-through and depth is empty and frankly just as insulting as its absence.

Then they just disappeared. Same old pattern.

But that’s why Grey’s Anatomy Season 20‘s cast was so thrilling. It was the first time that it felt like we’d have worthwhile successors who would properly usher in the next generation of the series.

Their introductions came with so many nostalgic callbacks to the OG interns. We listened to the iconic speech that Webber had recited 20 years earlier, and it was clear we were about to embark on a new journey.

Even their names aligned perfectly (Millins, Adams, Griffith, Yasuda, Kwan — MAGYK). Grey’s played with some of the archetypes we’d come to love in the OG interns without making them direct rip-offs of one another.

The new class could hold its own. On top of that, we had exciting developments. Learning that Lucas Adams was none other than Derek Shepherd’s nephew was such a genuine shock and emotional revelation.

It was the mark of a series that was cognizant of its legacy and intent on keeping it alive — nodding at its past while hinting at a bright future.

They even went so far as to have Mer unofficially take Simone Griffith under her wing. Learning about Simone as she came under Mer’s tutelage was great, mainly because it felt like a passing of the torch—an unspoken stamp of approval: this time, this new class, they were legit — emblematic of a new era.

And this batch of interns clicked into place, lounging in the same spots the OG interns did, having the same types of interactions, even down to how Benson “Blue” Kwan slowly worked himself into the fold, much like Alex Karev.

By the time we got to some of them sharing a house — Mer’s house, it felt like we struck gold on Grey’s Anatomy’s ability to reinvent itself.

It was the perfect reset for a series like this. So, what happened?

The catalyst for things starting to fall apart was Mika Yasuda’s departure from the series after being one of the most compelling characters in the herd.

Her departure also ended a fresh, interesting romance worth investing in: Mika and Jules.

We lost out on Teddy having a protege and interesting stories about a young woman feeling the grip of financial issues, which was a great undercurrent storyline.

From there, it felt like Grey’s completely botched a gift. One of its primary mistakes was not allowing these new characters to take center stage and not trusting them to hold viewers’ interest.

Every moment they spent shifting to most of the “veterans” felt frustrating and redundant. Instead of learning more about Jules’ unorthodox background, we get the same relationship drama with Teddy and Owen.

Diving into Blue’s experience attending medical school on an island didn’t take precedence, but whatever trite storyline they had to make Jo miserable did.

Grey’s never figured out how to shift some of the veteran characters to the background so that these new ones — the ones who are supposed to actually represent the new era of Grey’s Anatomy— could really shine.

The series had the perfect setup for so many arcs with these characters and never capitalized on them.

Lucas Adams being a Shepherd was fantastic at first, but it never really amounted to much. We still don’t know which Shepherd sister is his mother, and at this rate, we probably never will.

His presence was the perfect opportunity to give Amelia a worthwhile storyline that didn’t waste her. Yet we barely see this aunt and nephew interact —even when they apparently live together now.

Lucas even had a fascinating ADHD arc that showed nothing resembling follow-through or care.

Jules is deep into her third romantic entanglement. The casual bond with Blue gave way to a heartrending but frustratingly unfinished love story with Mika. And now, we’re in a slow-burning, will-they/won’t-they with Winston.

It doesn’t even have the spark of the other litany of power dynamic romances, and that’s only partly because Winston is a dull character who probably never should’ve lasted on the series as long as he has, respectfully.

Mostly, it just feels like they don’t know what to do with Jules. But then, the same applies to Blue, whose storylines have also just revolved around his love life.

Simone’s love triangle with Lucas and newcomer Wes is tepid at best.

It’s also a far cry from the girl we first met, who genuinely seemed to be on a path towards greatness, navigating the practice of medicine in the same hospital where she lost her mother.

She went from a character with all the potential in the world to another simply going through the motions because of underbaked, recycled plots.

The lack of effort into exploring these characters is tough enough, but the shallow exploration of respective romances only makes it worse.

There’s no real passion for medicine, no drive, ambition, or competitiveness. The mentorships are lacking, and most days we can’t even pinpoint which specialities they’re supposed to be interested in.

Grey’s Anatomy finally landed a new batch of characters who easily could have carried the series forward in exciting new ways while still honoring the show’s legacy.

And then … they dropped the scalpel.

It’s puzzling because they had all the components and ingredients to create something special (capable, dynamic actors, intriguing characters, narrative possibility) — but the series just doesn’t cook.

We could’ve had a Grey’s renaissance, but instead, we’re coasting on nostalgia and routine.

Twenty years later, we’re still here, tuned in, committed because once upon a time, Grey’s Anatomy earned our commitment, and being tied to a show’s legacy makes you feel something.

We just wish the series itself still made us feel something, too.

Let’s keep the conversation going — it’s the only way the good stuff survives.
Say something in the comments, share if you’re moved to, and keep reading. Independent voices need readers like you.

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.